How to Evaluate Colleges and Universities



How to Evaluate Colleges and Universities

Between all the unsolicited mail you're getting from NoIdea U., college fairs, and everyone you know offering their opinions, how do you figure out which school would be best for you? Here are some guidelines to follow to avoid common pitfalls and make the right decision.

Where to go?

You should spend time thinking about the "must-haves" of a college. For some, location is an important factor. For others, size (big or small) definitely matters. Does the school have a strong athletics program? Are students very intellectual? Are you interested in a school's drama or art department? Different students have different needs and interests. Find out which schools are a potential fit for you.

Check that price again.

At first glance, a state school may seem to cost a fraction of the price of a private college or university. However, many students at state schools don't end up graduating in four years. Check that state school's four-year graduation rate before choosing it over a private school for financial reasons alone reasons. Get tips on financing your college education.

Talk to alumni from your high school.

Contact someone from your high school who's currently attending a particular college or university. Asking just any student at a college his or her opinion of the school can be helpful, but won't offer the same insight as someone whose background is similar to yours.

Stats worth noting

While rankings can vary widely and don't necessarily give you relevant information, you should find out a school's freshman year retention rate (it should be 93% or better). These both reflect how students feel about the school—if they like it enough to stay, and if they remember it fondly enough to give money after graduating. If you're applying for financial aid, definitely check the average percentage of demonstrated need met. This number is much more telling than just finding out the dollar amount of the average aid package.

Some really important numbers

You should find out all you can about the campus crime statistics. New federal legislation requires colleges to produce and report campus crime stats. Try to read between the lines on this one. If you are in love with a school that has a "high" crime rate, do some investigating; that rate could be attributed to nothing more than a rash of bike thefts. But make sure you're not getting into an unmanageable situation. Don't hesitate to contact campus security directly to discuss this issue.

The Department of Education has a compilation of three years of campus crime statistics on its website. You can view a breakdown of crimes reported from 1998-2000 by category.

Scoping the digs

Maybe you think you have no time to visit prospective campuses. Then don't come blaming us when you wind up living in a dorm with roaches the size of rats, and rats the size of...well, you get the idea. This is where you will be living for at least four years. Is the food edible? Does the school guarantee housing? How are the dorms? Are the bathrooms clean? If you don't think you'd be able to live there, you probably shouldn't try. This is why campus visits are so important.

While you're there, find out how wired your prospective campus is. This goes beyond the number of computers in the school's computer lab. Are there T1 connections in all dorm rooms? Are undergradds required to bring a computer? (This adds to the price tag too!)

Don't forget to ask an admissions officer, or a knowledgeable guide, about other comparable colleges. You should ask something along the lines of "What other colleges might I be interested in?" It's probably not something to bring up at an admissions interview, but on a standard campus visit, it's a good way to gauge how this college sees itself (or would like to be seen), as well as another way to expand your list of target schools.

COMMUNITY
THE BUZZ
college admissions tips
Get tools and tips for the college admissions process!
Welcome Classes of 2009and 2010
Special resources to get the Classes of '09 and '10 started in the admissions process.

Insights from a Former Ivy League Admissions Officer

Parents, PTA/PTO Groups, Educators/Counselors —Learn about Kaplan's in-school test prep program.
Read College Admission Surveys

Get the scoop on 100s of colleges: Harvard, Duke, NYU, Stanford, more!
www.vault.com