The Lighter Side of the Law – An Ode to Pi

March 25, 2013
Stuart Kovinsky

Everybody loves PiAlthough there’s no math on the LSAT (a fact for which many a prospective law student has thanked her lucky stars), today’s post has a mathematical bent: in honour of the recently celebrated Pi Day (3/14), we’re going to look at the lighter side of the law – specifically, one Indiana politician’s attempt to round off pi.

Before we get to the truth of the story, let’s debunk the common myth: no one actually tried to pass a law rounding pi off to an even (or odd) 3. There was an April Fool’s hoax which gathered almost War of the Worldsian fervour before it was quashed, but no such bill was ever introduced in any modern legislature.

However, that doesn’t mean that no one has ever tried any pi shenanigans (pinanigans?). While the Indiana Pi Bill (the popular name for bill #246 of the 1897 sitting of the Indiana General Assembly) didn’t specifically legislate a value for pi (in fact, it never mentioned the world’s tastiest transcendental number by name), it did attempt to “square the circle” – overlooking that such action had been proven impossible a mere 15 years earlier.

So, how did this geometrical travesty occur? An Indiana doctor and amateur mathematician (emphasis on the “amateur”), Edwin J. Goodwin, convinced an Indiana Representative that Goodwin had discovered a correct way to square a circle, and that by passing the law Indiana would blaze new mathematical ground, make life considerably simpler for future generations of middle school students and, as an added benefit, make the Representative famous for taking the initiative.

How was disaster nearly averted? After the Bill made the preliminary rounds and was well on its way to becoming a law it serendipitously ended up in the hands of an actual mathematician, who quickly recognized it’s blatant falsity.

What are the takeaways from this near debacle?

1) Support the separation of Math and State;

2) Every legislature should keep a real mathematician on hand, just in case;

3) Everybody loves pi, even if some of people misunderstand it; and

4) Whether you’re dealing with geometry, law or the LSAT, avoid amateurs and put your faith in the hands of experts.

Stuart Kovinsky

Stuart Kovinsky I'm Stuart Kovinsky, an out-of-the-closet LSAT geek from Toronto. I've been teaching for Kaplan for over 20 years (not counting a 5 year break to practice as a commercial litigator at a big Toronto firm) and, working both as a teacher and an admissions consultant, have coached a lot of students to their top choice schools. I'm also an ultimate frisbee enthusiast - when not in the classroom or behind the keyboard you'll often find me on the field.

About Kaplan

We know test prep. We invented it. Through innovative technology and a personalized approach to learning, we’ll equip you with the test insights and advice you need to achieve your personal best. Results, guaranteed.*

Kaplan is accredited by the Accrediting Council for Continuing Education & Training (ACCET), a U.S. Department of Education nationally recognized agency. Test names and other trademarks are the property of the respective trademark holders. None of the trademark holders are endorsed by nor affiliated with Kaplan or this website. *Higher Score Guarantee: Conditions and restrictions apply. For complete guarantee eligibility requirements, visit © Copyright Kaplan, Inc. All Rights Reserved.